Direct indexing

Keep more of what your index earns

Own the individual stocks in an index instead of a single fund. You get the market exposure you want, plus the ability to harvest losses stock by stock, offset gains elsewhere in your life, and shape the portfolio around you.

  • 100% fiduciary
  • No commissions
  • Shares held in your name
Illustrative year Hypothetical $500,000 portfolio

Index return

+12.0%

Losses harvested

$27,500

Individual holdings

  • Technology stock A+31%
  • Health care stock B−18% · harvested
  • Energy stock C−24% · harvested
  • Financials stock D+9%
  • Consumer stock E−11% · harvested

Hypothetical illustration for educational purposes only. Not a projection or the result of any actual account.

“Even in a year the index goes up, many of the stocks inside it go down. A fund hides those losses. Direct indexing lets you use them.”

Huron Investments

Tax efficient

Losses harvested from individual stocks can offset capital gains from stock compensation, a business sale, real estate, or other investments, and up to $3,000 of ordinary income each year.

Customizable

Exclude your employer’s stock, underweight a sector you already have too much of, or screen out companies that conflict with your values, all while staying close to the benchmark.

Fiduciary oversight

Your portfolio is managed by an advisor legally required to act in your best interest, with harvesting coordinated against the rest of your tax picture, not run in isolation.

How it works

How does direct indexing help you save on taxes?

An index fund is one security. If the fund is up, you have no loss to claim, even though dozens or hundreds of the companies inside it fell. When you own those companies directly, each one has its own cost basis, and each one can be harvested on its own.

  1. 01

    Own the index, stock by stock

    We buy the individual companies in your chosen benchmark, weighted to track it closely.

  2. 02

    Monitor for losses

    Positions are reviewed regularly. When a holding drops meaningfully below its purchase price, it becomes a harvesting candidate.

  3. 03

    Sell and replace

    We sell the losing position to realize the loss and buy a similar, but not substantially identical, stock so your market exposure stays intact.

  4. 04

    Use the loss

    Harvested losses offset gains this year. Up to $3,000 of any remaining net loss offsets ordinary income, and the rest carries forward with no expiration.

A simple example

Say you have $100,000 of long-term capital gains from vesting RSUs you sold, and you are in the top federal bracket (20% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax).

If your direct index harvests $40,000 of losses that year, those losses cancel out $40,000 of the gain before tax is figured.

Index fund only$23,800 federal tax
With $40,000 harvested$14,280 federal tax
$9,520 less federal tax due this year

Hypothetical. $100,000 × 23.8% = $23,800; $60,000 × 23.8% = $14,280. State taxes not included. Harvesting usually lowers the cost basis of the replacement shares, so part of the benefit is a deferral rather than a permanent saving, unless the shares are later donated or passed on with a step-up in basis.

Beyond harvesting

More ways owning the stocks directly can help at tax time

Offset concentrated stock gains

Harvested losses can be paired with gradual sales of a large, low-basis position, helping you diversify without one large tax bill.

Choose which tax lots to sell

When you need cash, we can sell the specific lots with the highest basis or with losses, keeping realized gains as low as possible.

Give appreciated shares

Donating your most appreciated individual stocks to charity or a donor-advised fund can let you deduct fair market value and avoid the gain entirely.

No fund-level distributions

Mutual funds can pass out capital gains when other shareholders redeem. In a direct index, you only realize gains when trades are made in your own account.

Bank losses for later

Unused net capital losses carry forward indefinitely, building a reserve you can apply to a future home sale, business exit, or rebalance.

Wash-sale coordination

We watch your other accounts and your employer stock purchases so harvested losses aren’t disallowed by the 30-day wash-sale rule.

Direct index the S&P 500®, Nasdaq-100®, and more

Track broad U.S. and international markets, or focus on a size, style, or sector that fits your plan.

  • S&P 500®
  • Nasdaq-100®
  • Russell 1000®
  • Russell 2000®
  • Dow Jones Industrial Average®
  • CRSP U.S. Total Market
  • MSCI EAFE (ADRs)
  • S&P MidCap 400®
  • Dividend focus
  • ESG / values-based
  • Sector tilts

Benchmark availability depends on the custodian and account size. Index names are trademarks of their respective owners.

See how it compares

Direct indexing versus the two most common ways to own an index.

Direct indexing Index ETF Index mutual fund
What you ownIndividual stocksFund sharesFund shares
Harvest losses on individual stocks✓——
Harvest losses in an up marketOftenRarelyRarely
Exclude employer stock or sectors✓——
Pick specific tax lots to sell or donate✓Fund level onlyFund level only
Exposed to other holders’ gains distributionsNoRarelyYes
Tracks the benchmarkClosely, with small tracking differenceVery closelyVery closely
Typical minimumHigherOne shareLow

General comparison for educational purposes. Specific products vary.

A tax-smart strategy for every type of portfolio

We match the approach to what you own today and what you need from it.

Core

Classic direct index

Track a broad benchmark with ongoing loss harvesting and the customizations you choose.

  • ✓Fund new cash or transfer existing stock
  • ✓Ongoing harvesting, most valuable in the early years
  • ✓Exclusions, sector limits, and values screens

Best for: investors with recurring gains to offset.

Transition

Diversify a concentrated position

Gradually unwind a large single-stock holding, using harvested losses to absorb the gains as you sell.

  • ✓Multi-year sale schedule built around your brackets
  • ✓Index built to exclude the stock and its close peers
  • ✓Pairs well with charitable gifting of low-basis shares

Best for: executives, founders, and long-tenured employees.

Enhanced

Long/short extension

Add modest leverage, such as a 130/30 structure, to create more positions that can generate losses over time.

  • ✓Harvesting potential beyond a long-only index
  • ✓Optional factor tilts such as quality or value
  • ✓Higher costs, financing charges, and risk

Best for: larger portfolios with significant gains to offset.

Leverage and short selling increase risk and may lead to losses greater than the amount invested. Suitability depends on your circumstances. Consult your tax advisor.

Why direct index with Huron

Fiduciary, always

As a Registered Investment Advisor, we are required to put your interests first. We don’t earn commissions on what we recommend.

Your account, your name

Assets are held at an independent qualified custodian in your name. You can see every share you own.

Part of your whole plan

Harvesting is coordinated with your equity compensation, giving, estate plan, and strategies like box spread borrowing.

See what direct indexing could do for you

Bring your recent tax return and brokerage statements. We’ll review your gains, concentrated positions, and goals, and tell you plainly whether direct indexing makes sense.

Frequently asked questions

What is direct indexing?

Direct indexing means owning the individual stocks that make up an index, in roughly the same weights, in your own account. The goal is index-like returns with more control over taxes and holdings.

How is it different from an ETF?

An ETF is a single security with a single cost basis. Direct indexing gives you hundreds of positions, each with its own basis, so losses in individual companies can be harvested even when the overall index is up. ETFs are simpler and cheaper to hold; direct indexing adds tax and customization flexibility.

How much can I really save?

It depends on market volatility, when you fund the account, your tax bracket, and whether you have gains to offset. Harvesting opportunities are typically largest in the first few years and shrink as positions appreciate. Much of the benefit is tax deferral, which becomes permanent if shares are donated or held until death.

Can I exclude my employer’s stock?

Yes. Excluding your employer, and its close competitors, is one of the most common customizations. It reduces concentration risk and helps avoid wash sales with ESPP or RSU activity.

What is the wash-sale rule?

If you sell a security at a loss and buy the same or a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale, in any of your accounts including IRAs, the loss is disallowed for now. We use similar replacement stocks and coordinate across accounts to stay clear of it.

Is direct indexing right for me?

It tends to fit investors in higher tax brackets who hold taxable accounts and have, or expect, capital gains, such as from stock compensation, a concentrated position, or a business or property sale. It offers little tax benefit in IRAs or 401(k)s.

Can I transfer stocks I already own?

Often, yes. Existing positions can be moved in and folded into the index over time, with sales timed to manage the gains you realize.