Borrow against your portfolio instead of selling it
Selling appreciated stock triggers capital gains tax and removes that money from the market. A box spread loan at 4.5% lets you raise the same cash while your investments keep compounding. Enter your numbers to compare the two.
What is a box spread?
A box spread is a combination of four options on a broad index such as the S&P 500 (SPX) that together lock in a fixed value at expiration. To borrow, you sell the box: you receive cash today and owe a known, larger amount on the expiration date.
The gap between the two is your interest. Because the payoff is fixed no matter where the market goes, and SPX options are cleared through the Options Clearing Corporation, the rate is close to Treasury yields, often well below margin loan or bank rates.
How the interest is taxed
With a box spread you do not pay interest in the usual sense. Your "interest" shows up as a loss on the options position.
SPX options are Section 1256 contracts, so that loss is treated as 60% long-term and 40% short-term capital loss, no matter how long you hold the position. The positions are also marked to market every December 31, so you claim the loss year by year as it builds up, not only at the end.
Those capital losses offset your capital gains. Any loss left over offsets up to $3,000 of ordinary income each year, and the rest carries forward.
Why the after-tax rate is lower
If you have short-term gains, the short-term portion offsets income that would be taxed at ordinary rates, so each dollar of box spread interest can cut your tax bill by a meaningful amount. If you only have long-term gains, the whole loss offsets those instead, which still lowers your cost, just by less. Your real cost of borrowing is:
after-tax rate = box rate × (1 − blended tax rate)
A typical mortgage or margin loan does not get this treatment. Margin interest can be deducted only against investment income, and only if you itemize.
Example: 4.5% box spread in the top federal bracket
| Share of loss | Tax rate offset | Weighted | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Long-term portion (20% + 3.8% NIIT) | 60% | 23.8% | 14.3% |
| Short-term portion (37% + 3.8% NIIT) | 40% | 40.8% | 16.3% |
| Blended federal tax savings | 30.6% | ||
| After-tax borrowing rate: 4.5% × (1 − 30.6%) | ≈ 3.1% |
State income tax lowers the rate further. With a 5% state rate, the blended savings are about 35.6% and the after-tax rate falls to about 2.9%. The full benefit assumes you have enough capital gains each year to absorb the loss. The calculator below uses your tax settings to work out the after-tax borrowing rate and applies it to the loan cost.
Your situation
Adjust assumptions
What you keep after 10 years
Year by year
Each point shows what you would keep after tax and loan repayment if you sold everything that year. Hover or touch the chart to see a year.
See the numbers for each year
| Year | Box spread | Sell stock | Difference |
|---|
| Box spread | Sell stock | |
|---|---|---|
| Stock sold today | ||
| Capital gains tax paid today | ||
| Portfolio at end of horizon | ||
| Loan balance owed at end | ||
| Tax saved on box spread interest | ||
| Tax if you sell everything at end | ||
| Net after tax and loan |
How the comparison works
Both paths raise the same amount of cash today. Selling means selling enough stock that, after tax, you are left with that amount. Borrowing means the box spread supplies the cash and your whole portfolio stays invested.
- Tax rate is the federal long-term capital gains rate you select (20% by default), plus the 3.8% net investment income tax if you leave it checked, plus your state rate.
- The loan accrues interest at the box spread rate and is repaid in full at the end of the horizon. Each year, the interest creates a 60/40 capital loss that saves tax at your blended rate. Those savings are set aside against the loan, so the loan effectively grows at the after-tax borrowing rate. You can switch this off in the assumptions.
- To keep the comparison fair, both portfolios are fully sold at the end and taxed on their gains. Borrowing defers tax, so it does not erase it.
- Returns are treated as steady annual growth with no dividends or interim tax. The comparison turns against borrowing when your return falls below the loan rate.